The Crisis of Quality Investing

For more than a decade following the global financial crisis, investors took comfort in owning “quality” at almost any price. Capital consistently flowed into consumer staples, healthcare, and software, sectors assumed to offer resilience, pricing power, and durable growth. Over the past three to five years, however, that assumption has been increasingly challenged.

Former quality darlings, first staples and healthcare, and more recently software and information services, have begun to underperform not only tech-led growth, but also traditionally value-oriented sectors such as banks, miners, and semiconductors. As a result, investors are now starting to question whether there is any need to maintain exposure to quality at all.

We continue to believe that quality belongs at the heart of any long-term investment portfolio. It is essential to own businesses with durable franchises, terminal value, pricing power, resilience in the form of low operational gearing and strong balance sheets. Equally important is compounding potential, reflected in the ability to reinvest at high marginal returns on capital. Together, these characteristics should underpin strong shareholder returns over the medium to long term without undue volatility. A barbell approach that concentrates solely on the extremes of expensive growth and deep value is inherently risky and can lead to pronounced volatility at certain points in the cycle.

Where we differ, however, is in where investors can find these characteristics. They are not the exclusive preserve of a handful of sectors; rather, they can be found across a much broader range of businesses, provided there is sufficient selectivity. No sector is homogeneous that all its constituents possess these attributes to the same degree. As a result, the emphasis should be on stock selection rather than sector allocation. It is just as flawed to claim that all consumer staples are high quality as it is to argue that all banks are low quality.

One common mistake we see among investors seeking “quality” is the tendency to equate simple, easy-to-screen, backward-looking metrics, such as return on invested capital, with a genuine understanding of the durability of a company’s franchise, which is inherently complex and qualitative. ROIC is, at best, a proxy for quality: it offers clues, but never proof, as to which companies truly possess pricing power, competitive advantage, and the ability to compound over time. We would argue that the direction and rate of change in a company’s return on capital matter just as much as its most recently reported level. In other words, marginal returns on capital can be just as important as historical ones.

At the same time, the world is constantly evolving, and investors must remain alert to how quality can strengthen or erode over long cycles. While higher inflation and AI-driven technological disruption have led to renewed scrutiny of the pricing power and terminal value of certain consumer staples and software businesses, this does not invalidate the broader principle that pricing power and terminal value remain critical components of a resilient investment portfolio.

The final point to highlight is the importance of valuation discipline. Quality characteristics are no guarantee of a great shareholder return. They may underpin confidence in the sustainability of a company’s ability to generate cash or grow its earnings but in the long-term an overvalued asset is never a good investment. The market is starting to recognise that ‘quality at any price’ can be just as uncomfortable as deep value or aggressive growth investing. Quality characteristics must be applied more selectively and complemented by cyclical and restructuring opportunities as markets rotate. This isn’t the time to give up on quality. It’s the time to rethink the old shortcuts, question stale narratives, and take a fresh look at what quality really means and where it’s hiding.

JOHCM International Opportunities

Source: JOHCM as of December 31, 2025. Fund holdings are subject to change without notification.

ROIC stands for Return on Invested Capital and is a profitability or performance ratio that aims to measure the percentage return that a company earns on invested capital. (Source: Corporate Finance Institute) 

Professional investors only .

This is a marketing communication .

Issued and approved in the UK by J O Hambro Capital Management Limited (“JOHCML”) which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered office: Level 3, 1 St James’s Market, London SW1Y 4AH. Issued in the European Union by Perpetual Investment Services Europe Limited (“PISEL”) which is authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland. Registered office: 24 Fitzwilliam Place, Dublin 2, Ireland D02 T296. Issued in the United States by JOHCM (USA) Inc. (“JOHCMU”). Principal office: One Congress Street, Suite 3101, Boston, Massachusetts 02114. Issued in Singapore by JOHCM (Singapore) Pte Limited (“JOHCMS”) which is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Registered office: 138 Market Street, #15 04 CapitaGreen, Singapore 048946. References to “JOHCM” below are to JOHCML, JOHCMU, JOHCMS or PISEL as the context requires. Perpetual Group is a trading name of JOHCML and PISEL .

RISK CONSIDERATIONS: The strategy invests in international and emerging markets. International investments involve special risks, including currency fluctuation, lower liquidity, different accounting methods and economic and political systems, and higher transaction costs. These risks typically are greater in emerging markets. Such risks include new and rapidly changing political and economic structures, which may cause instability; underdeveloped securities markets; and higher likelihood of high levels of inflation, deflation or currency devaluations .

The views expressed are those of the portfolio manager as the date of posting, are subject to change, and may differ from the views of other portfolio managers or the firm as a whole. These opinions are not intended to be a forecast of future events, a guarantee of future results, or investment advice.

The distribution of this document in jurisdictions other than those referred to above may be restricted by law (“Restricted Jurisdictions”). Therefore, this document is not intended for distribution in any Restricted Jurisdiction and should not be passed on or copied to any person in such a jurisdiction .

Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. The value of an investment and the income from it can fall as well as rise as a result of market and currency fluctuations and you may not get back the amount originally invested .

Investing in companies in emerging markets involves higher risk than investing in established economies or securities markets. Emerging markets may have less stable legal and political systems, which could affect the safe-keeping or value of assets .

Investments may include shares in small-cap companies and these tend to be traded less frequently and in lower volumes than larger companies making them potentially less liquid and more volatile .

The information contained herein including any expression of opinion is for information purposes only and is given on the understanding that it is not a recommendation .

The information in this document does not constitute, or form part of, any offer to sell or issue, or any solicitation of an offer to purchase or subscribe for any funds or strategies described in this document; nor shall this document, or any part of it, or the fact of its distribution form the basis of, or be relied on, in connection with any contract .

Telephone calls to and from JOHCM may be recorded. Information on how personal data is handled can be found in the JOHCM Privacy Statement on its website: www.johcm.com

J O Hambro® and JOHCM® are registered trademarks of JOHCML.